USER     PASSWORD  
 Forgot username or password? Click here.
PLATFORM   Xbox360

Borderlands Review

GAME INFO
publisher: 2K Games
developer: Gearbox Software
genre: Shooters

MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
n/a
ESRB rating: M
homepage:
http://www.borderlandsthegame.com/

release date: Oct 23, 09 (released)
» All About Borderlands on ActionTrip


The weaponry in this game is definitely an aspect that takes up most of the player's time. We've enjoyed the practically unlimited amount of unique pistols, revolvers, combat rifles, shotguns, grenade launchers, snipers and grenades. Upgrading the grenades always gives you quite a bit to ponder. For instance, certain upgrades give your grenades the ability to heal team members, in addition to dealing damage to enemies. Another solution is adding diverse improvements that add corrosive damage, shock damage, fire damage, etc. No matter which weapon you're upgrading, it requires a tactical approach, especially if you're not playing alone.

The pre-release change of the design and art style of Borderlands was one of the smartest decisions Gearbox ever made. The characters, environments and the animation are quite good and have a certain appeal that's been refreshed with an added dose of humor. The humor is also present in some of the wacky voiceovers, which is why we regret the developers didn't spend extra time creating more cut-scenes and voiced dialogue.

Frankly, Borderlands can use a richer character backdrop and a generally better narrative. Everything players might be interested in knowing about Pandora is written in quest logs, although these are often restricted to the specific tasks at hand and offer precious little about the regions and inhabitants in Pandora. This is one of the greatest flaws of the game that excels during single-player mode. Now, apart from having a blast in co-op, I did experience a large portion of the main campaign in solo mode (so much so that my character reached level 33). The gameplay was still very satisfying, but if you hunger for a decent narrative and deep characterization, I'm afraid Borderland may come as a disappointment.

Borderlands has other flaws. As it usually is with games nowadays, the first issues are related to AI. In Borderlands, the AI generally behaves acceptably, giving you plenty to tackle. Even so, enemies get confused or just forget they have to attack and even occasionally ignore the fact that they're being fired upon. As it turns out, vehicles are not entirely up to par with other satisfying aspects of the game. The physics don't always work out and there are plenty of unexpected hindrances on the road that tend to spoil the fun. The technical issues on the Xbox 360 continue in the form of sudden and severe frame-rate drops - these usually occur when players are fighting in larger areas and there are a lot of objects that need to be rendered in the background.

There are only a handful of negative elements that keep this game from getting an Editor's Choice Award from us. It's safe to say I had my doubts at first, but now I'm really glad I played it.

Overlooking certain flaws, Borderlands ultimately delivers what players are bound to expect from it - pure and addictive RPG-flavored FPS action, extremely engaging co-op and altogether a vast and mysterious world waiting to be explored. Gearbox made a great foundation for potential DLCs and sequels. We only hope that the next installment brings more substance, with a richer history of Pandora, additional work poured into some of the characters and generally a more detailed story.

PAGE 1 2

USER SCORE
9.3
YOUR SCORE
RATE IT 0.0
ACTIONTRIP SCORE
8.7   Very Good


HIGHS
This first-person shooter offers memorable co-op moments on top of highly addictive and challenging RPG-style gameplay, great art and music, plenty of quests and a virtually endless amount of weapons;

LOWS
Enemies get confused or just forget they have to attack and even ignore the fact that they're being fired upon, a few problems with the vehicle mechanics, frame-rate slows down severely in certain, larger, areas.

RATINGS GUIDE




16 post(s)
Reader Comments
mmacarthur [mail] Oct 27 2009, 05:04 am EDT
Got this on pre-order hopefully be here Friday looking forward to some co-op with my mates. :)
Superastic [mail] Oct 27 2009, 05:35 am EDT
I'm already playing at work with 3 other guys. Hell, there's 12 of us playing right now. Cool game.
Vader [STAFF] [mail] Oct 27 2009, 05:36 am EDT
Glad to know it.
SpaceMonkey [mail] Oct 27 2009, 06:12 am EDT
There are few games that makes me come back for more, Borderlands despite it's short comings are one of those games.

I do agreed with the questionable AI, they could have made it more realistic instead of Serious Sam esque AI.

I remember the original Goldeneye for the N64. When your bullet hits the wall next to an unsuspecting enemy, he actually reacts to the impact (looking over his shoulder investigating) instead of YOU which is holding a sniper from miles away.

That is ultimately what borderlands is lacking, many times I've seen enemies pointing guns to the left or right while side stepping towards me. That kills the illusion for me.

Every times that happened it yells at me "you're playing a game!! and this is an overlooked flaw!! deal with it!!".

Despite all that, I thoroughly enjoyed the game and is "obtaining" the pc version right now to continue on (I already bought the x360 version, and refused to buy the same game again for another medium).
PanteraFan666 [mail] Oct 27 2009, 06:23 am EDT
this game kicks A#$, i would have give it 9, its fun. Its extremely fun on multiplayer, killing as a team and trading weapons.
thestewieman [mail] Oct 27 2009, 06:51 am EDT
lets now review it without xbox live gold..
pc wins that quite easily.

a special link for cheddar if he feels the need to comment:
http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/8734/dsc0385​0zw.jpg
  Vader: Cheddar?
thestewieman: he keeps hammering on that the xbox360 is the best, and ever...
PanteraFan666: pc games suck, why would you buy a game for your computer.
Cheddar: I very openly praised the PS3 here on AT for its latest pric...
Cheddar: Anyway, I will NEVER argue that a console shooter is better ...
shadowwolf [mail] Oct 27 2009, 07:47 am EDT
I bought borderlands on the PS3 last week, and I'm taking it back today. The reasons are: Atleast as far as I got in the game, the freaking art style doesn't change at all and it gets really boring. Its the same problem I had with Fallout 3.

Also co-op can be fun, but man are there a lot of problems with it. It looked like to me that if one person in the group has completed a quest, no one else, while grouped with said person, can get that quest. This leads to huge problems of nothing to do but farm mobs on the map. On top of that you better make sure everyone is fairly close in level, which is something thats really hard to do in a game thats as easy to level in as this, otherwise the mobs just get harder to kill and the new person doesn't bring much to the table.

On top of that, looting is seriously fucked up in co-op, I mean free-for-all loot, major fucking mistake. Its too easy for everyone else to grab loot and then all of a sudden, one player may not have upgraded their weapon for several levels, which ends up meaning that they can't kill shit. Plus as far as I could tell you get the same amount of money and loot in co-op, however due to 4 players splitting it up, all of a sudden you are actually worse off than in single player. You get less gear, so less chance up upgrades you may really need, and less funds to buy stuff at the store with.

Additionally the weapons level up in power way too quickly, since it can easily be 5-10 levels before you find a replacement gun, just due to the random nature of the loot, including the store, which offer way too little loot. The problem comes from enemies health levels going up, as if the devs expected you to be getting new guns, and all of a sudden mobs are taking 2 clips to kill because for the love of god you can't fucking get a new weapon.

Also horribly imbalanced guns, a good sniper can mow down people at range, which is expected, and then still easily no scope mobs up close for the same damage, which I might add is like 5 x shotgun damage. Shotguns are complete shit in this game, and you are better off using melee than those pieces of shit. Pistols seem a little op too, as they have decent clip sizes, good accuracy at medium range, heck better than a sniper, some of the best damage of any gun and fast firing and reloading.

All in all it is a good game. I really do respect them for the world they designed, I just wish there was some different art to look at. Loot being the main focus of the game, seriously hurts its multiplayer by practically making you go farm loot in single player just so you can kill stuff your level again. Enemies start getting repetitive really quick, as you end up fighting a lot of the same mobs. However there is good variety to those mobs and the fights do end up frantic and fun. In the end I wouldn't give it higher than an 8, since co-op is such a big focus, but its somewhat broken, and single player gets dull pretty quickly for me at least.
skribb [mail] Oct 27 2009, 08:11 am EDT
"Borderlands has other welcomed gameplay elements such as the dying."



Sounds like... a lotta fun!
Vader [STAFF] [mail] Oct 27 2009, 08:48 am EDT
Yeah, I edited that part in the last minute, looks like a left something out... :) anyway, fixed it now.
WereGerbel [mail] Oct 27 2009, 09:55 am EDT
Fair and even review, and you have to admit you got all giddy listening to the intro for the first time, and second time. It's not going to in a sense revolutionize the genre, but after playing the serious games out there a little sensible humor and mayhem gives you that warm fuzzy feeling when you shoot the shotgun toting midgets.

And that damn robot 'Watch me everyone, check me out I'm dancing, I'm dancing!' LOL!! Neat.

And man the item drops, crap, you find one combat rifle that explodes your enemies, then you find another one with a zoom, increased damaged AND 2x explodes your enemies. -sigh- So many toys to kill with..
However the driving mechanics could use a little tweaking, and wouldn't have been sweet to get a skill to combine weapons, the castoff purples with the blues and so on.

In short I really like this game, not too cartoony, violence aint the driving force, and it's a long haul, don't wait up for me game. It's just a relief to actually enjoy a game these days.
Vodoo [mail] Oct 27 2009, 11:10 am EDT
too MMO-ish for me.

by the way, Torchlight is out and it's a very cute homage to Diablo and the hack-slash genre. that's what has ME hooked.

tastes are different as always but sometimes it is amusing when they all converge to testify some are true gems among barter hands.
  Alchi: Hey thanks vodoo. Torchlight looks nice. So far I'm interest...
im_stardust [mail] Oct 27 2009, 11:21 am EDT
So it's nice to play in single player?
  im_stardust: Iz naaaissssss!!
Vader: Sure it's okay.
cybergod [mail] Oct 27 2009, 02:51 pm EDT
Played it for at least an hour and all I encountered was strafing dogs and some humanoids to kill. Game is linear as hell, wtf you guys. Strafing dogs!!
KeepSmilin [mail] Oct 27 2009, 04:29 pm EDT
Played on PS3. While the combat is fun, i don't really like the fact that there is very little meaningful character interaction. But at least they nailed the fps aspect. Wonder when the mods will start rolling in...
thestewieman [mail] Oct 27 2009, 07:21 pm EDT
will get it once it hit the bargain bin ;)
  mmacarthur: Its £20 on ShopTo right now for PC - one more reason to be a...
Cheddar [mail] Nov 21 2009, 01:40 pm EST
Borderlands plays better on a gamepad than any console shooter I've ever played before, in terms of sheer mechanics. Not sure how that is, exactly, but it's true. So that's nice.

That said, of course the PC version is better than the console version. That's true by default for ANY first-person-shooter, and will remain that way as long as you can't use a keyboard and mouse with a console. I wouldn't be caught dead arguing otherwise.
  COMMENTS PAGE 1  


POST A COMMENT
Username:Password:



SEND THIS PAGE TO A FRIEND
Easily fill in your friends' emails to send them this page.
 
 
BACK TO TOP
TOP VIDEOS
VOTING POLL

Single-player RPG or MMORPG?

MMORPG.
Single-player RPG.
» view results
» view poll archives
TOP SCREENSHOTS
See previous images
See next images
 
 
TOP COMICS
Top Video Game AdvertizingPrototype 2 - No Suspicious ActivityThe Life of Max Payne 2