USER     PASSWORD  
 Forgot username or password? Click here.
Back to home
Back to home
GC 2008 Show Coverage

LATEST NEWS

LATEST BABE
9.1 out of
65 votes


LATEST COMIC
"Gaming is An Illness"
Aug. 19, 2008


LATEST CHEATS
LATEST VIDEOS
LATEST DOWNLOADS
ACTIONTRIP POLL
Star Trek Online vs. KotOR MMOG:
» view results
» view poll archives


FEATURED LINKS
FUNNY VIDEOS
By CRAVEONLINE.COM
CONTACT US
NEWSLETTER
Subscribe to our free
weekly newsletter:



USER SCORE
/
YOUR SCORE
RATE IT 0.0
ACTIONTRIP SCORE
8.2
Very Good

HIGHS
Compelling and intuitive design, very easy to get into, solid multiplayer, great visuals, comes highly recommended for train buffs;

LOWS
Technical glitches, can be repetitive at times.

RATINGS GUIDE


TOP STORIES


TOP COMICS Disable thumbnails
"E3 2009"
07/28/2008 Jojic/Grabovic
21081 views
"Gaming is An Illness"
08/19/2008 Jojic/Grabovic
20148 views
"A Worthy Sacrifice"
07/09/2008 Jojic/Grabovic
8110 views

TOP BABES Disable thumbnails
Last month's 8.8
08/22/2008
30236 views
Last month's 8.4
08/23/2008
19389 views
Last week's 8.9
08/25/2008
17280 views
Last week's 7.8
08/26/2008
12849 views
Last week's 8.8
08/27/2008
11061 views

TOP VIDEOS Disable thumbnails
Need for Speed Undercover Trailer
1:04
Need for Speed Undercover Teaser
1:19
Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War 2 GC 2008 Trailer
2:57
Tomb Raider Underworld 'Becoming Lara Croft' Trailer
3:59
The Witcher Enhanced Edition Trailer
1:36

TOP CHEATS


ActionTrip's unique gaming MySpace layouts! Click here to grab them!
PLATFORM   PC

Sid Meier's Railroads! Review

GAME INFO
publisher: 2K Games
developer: Firaxis Games
genre: Management

MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
PIV 1400, 512MB RAM, 2GB HDD, 64MB video card
ESRB rating: E
homepage:
www.sidsrailroads.com/

release date: Oct 17, 06 (released)
» All About Sid Meier's Railroads! on ActionTrip


November 02, 2006
Ure "Vader" Paul

The summer of 2006 will go down in gaming history as a relatively dreary period for PC owners. Luckily, there's no need to panic, cause autumn always brings a few decent games our way. Clearly enough, developers are jumping on the bandwagon and gearing up for the highly potential console market. As you all know, the spotlight is currently aimed at Microsoft's Xbox 360 and, of course, the industry is bracing itself for Sony's upcoming PS3 console. Well, after seeing what the Xbox 360 is capable of, I must admit it's hard not to get caught up in the frenzy. Still, I cannot deny my deep-rooted need for straightforward and traditional home-PC entertainment. Lately, I seem to find refuge in sim-based classics such as SimCity 4: Rush Hour and the Tycoon series. Hm, either I'm growing old way too fast, or I simply might be craving a different kind of incentive to carry out my assignments... I therefore urge our Editor-in-Chief to pre-order me a PS3 or one of those snazzy new Wii things (purely for business purposes, of course).

Unfortunately, 2lions didn't fall for that one.

He has struck a chord though, after offering me a chance to review a retail build of Sid Meier's Railroads. In light of my abovementioned fondness for sim games, I happily accepted this task.

Before I begin, I must stress that I'm not one of those eccentric types that likes to hang around the basement and spend countless hours fiddling around with his absurdly expensive train set. Then again, I've always kind of liked trains and I am partial to train-travel, so I thought this could be an interesting ride altogether.

Anyhow, upon installing Sid Meier's Railroads, I was immediately taken by the game's intuitive design and the straightforward interface. This way, players are given a chance to enjoy the game and its numerous traits, regardless of their previous experiences with train sims. So, all it takes is going through the simplified 5-minute tutorial, and you should be ready for the challenges that come with the game's single-player and multiplayer modes.

Like I said, Sid Meier's Railroads boasts a unique way of allowing the player to get into the game as quickly and easily as possible. In addition, several single-player scenarios are on offer as well as a range of well-designed multiplayer maps. After playing the game for quite some time, I managed to master the difficulties of the train business. Your aim is to dominate the entire region by constructing and maintaining a fully functional and up-to-the-minute railroad system. The game also stretches beyond handling mere everyday chores, like placing tracks on the map, purchasing the latest locomotive and picking out the best routes for trains. Each city on the map represents a potential foundation for particular industries. Appropriate resources are required, of course, to increase local businesses and production. For instance, establishing a booming newspaper corporation in, say, Philadelphia, quite naturally denotes a regular supply of paper. Consequently, you'll also need to think about connecting certain cities with timber companies to boost the fabrication of paper.

Once a certain industry launches, you will be able to take part in auctions for patents and other businesses. After winning an auction, the player receives a percentage and can enjoy profits in accordance with the success of the business in question. This always makes for a good investment. Bear in mind that each train involves considerable maintenance costs, so you won't get very far without investing wisely into upcoming industries. If that doesn't quell your thirst for financial challenges, you can always buy and sell stock and bid for potential production facilities.

The bad news is that after playing the game for a while, it might get a bit tedious. At first, I couldn't figure out why exactly, but it soon became clear that the development team might have taken things a tad too far when simplifying the design as well as the gameplay. As a result, players who were hoping to find a complex gameplay concept, with more detailed economics, additional train customization, could easily be disappointed to a certain degree.

There are many good points though. Namely, that Firaxis managed to disregard any aspects of the gameplay that could burden the player or create unwanted micromanagement issues. Also, there's a choice of over 30 different industries to purchase and organize, 20 resources to manage and over 30 unique train models to produce and utilize. Each scenario revolves around completing a wide range of tasks, after which you can look forward to many cool bonuses - thus improving your cash balance and instituting a more stable economy for future endeavors.

Let's not forget the multiplayer mode, which allows you to edit maps and create your personal locomotive empire, while competing against other players. Things can heat up when you start bidding for businesses that just started out on the market. All in all, it was great fun.

Looking at the graphics, Sid Meier's Railroads includes just about everything you can hope to find in a train-sim. Realistic and colorful surroundings and detailed locomotive models manage to capture the player's eye almost straight away. As your very own mass transit system begins to take shape, you'll be able to acknowledge the developer's admirable attention to detail. The designers have done a fabulous job obviously, while the animation team clearly made a great effort to bring all of those cute little trains to life. By the same token, the audio is solid and blends perfectly with the in-game ambiance. While forming your ideal train domain, you will be treated to a pleasing variety of cheerful sounding country-flavored tunes.

On the technical side of things, we weren't all that happy with the game, especially in view of the fact that it managed to cause severe frame-rate issues on modest rigs (Athlon 64 3000+, Radeon 9800 XT and 1 GB of RAM).

In closing, this game is catchy and has a little something for everyone. But we sure as hell hope that Firaxis plans to fix the aforementioned technical slip ups with a patch of some sort. Looking back on games like SimCity 4, this isn't the first time they leave such issues unresolved. Even though SC4 was excellent, it ended up crammed with bugs, on top of having exceedingly steep hardware requirements.

All things considered, all train devotees mustn't pass on this one. In all honesty, I believe that a choo-choo addict dwells somewhere within all of us, so everyone should give the game a try or rent it at the very least. You won't be disappointed with the content and gameplay it has to offer.

PAGE 1




7 post(s)
Reader Comments
Little Beaver [mail] Nov 02 2006, 03:03 pm EST
Last game i expected to see here :P

Welcome back V
  Vader: Thanks LB. It's good to be back :)
King Speedy [mail] Nov 02 2006, 03:55 pm EST
That grin scares me.
  Cheddar: I know, right?
KommanderKool [mail] Nov 02 2006, 05:38 pm EST
Well, I found my new timesink to replace WoW. I mean, who doesn't want to battle their friends in a railroad building battle to the proverbial death???
Vader [STAFF] [mail] Nov 02 2006, 11:16 pm EST
Hey, now you're just trying to deny the choo-choo addict that dwells inside you.
Staljin [mail] Nov 03 2006, 12:46 am EST
The multiplayer is a lot of fun
Vodoo [mail] Nov 03 2006, 04:40 am EST
not as mondo ultra terrifically cool as i expected.
  craigww_22: Nope.
mikeblas [mail] Nov 11 2006, 08:55 am EST
I'm a little surprised that none of the problems in the game are discussed here.

It's crashed every time I've played it. Fortunately, there's an auto save and I can usually recover most of my progress. But it's annoying just the same.

The game has plenty of bugs. While the economic model is simpler, laying out track is actually harder. Double- and triple-run track is important for keeping traffic flow going. But laying it out in this game, and figuring out why it isn't working, is not at all fun. The manual says that crossovers must be manually added between parallel runs, which is fine. But most of the time that I try to lay a crossover, I get a bridge with switchbacks.

Inexplicably, deliveries I see happen while tracking a train aren't counted towards my game goals. My Pittsburgh-to-Chicago train has made six trips, each with five cars of steel. But the goals screen says I've picked up zero shipments of steel from Pittsburgh. Why is that?

Stations that I've clearly laid track between might be marked as unreachable o nthe map. No explanation, no way to diagnose the disconnected track.

The game will often "hang" trains. That is, a train will get stuck in a loop. If I routed it from Indianapolis to Detroit, I might find it near Fort Wayne turning itself in circles endlessly.

I can't figure out how to rename a train. It's difficult to find a train; I know I have something that goes from Chicago to Saint Louis, but where is it? I want to chagne it -- but I can't if I can't find it!

The map views are very difficult to use. There's a tiny map in the lower left corner, but it's hard to use for finding resources and consumers. The view can't be rotated, making it difficult to see what's in a valley, behind a mountain, or beneath a clump of trees.

I enjoy playing games, but I don't like grinding against bugs. I expected a lot more from the fourth generation of this game.
  COMMENTS PAGE 1  


POST A COMMENT
Username:Password:



SEND THIS PAGE TO A FRIEND
Easily fill in your friends' emails to send them this page.
 
 
BACK TO TOP
 
Partner Sites:    CraveOnline.com    PSP3D.com
© 1999 - 2008 ActionTrip.com All Rights Reserved - Terms of Use - Privacy Statement - Site Map