Forgot username or password? Click here.

The Banner Saga Review

publisher: Stoic Studio
developer: Stoic Studio
genre: RPG

ESRB rating: RP

release date: Jan 14, 14
» All About The Banner Saga on ActionTrip

With nearly two months behind us and the God-awful dead post-Christmas season almost coming to an end, Stoic Studio title The Banner Saga marches into view in all its artistic majesty. You may not have played the game, but it’s quite possible you’ve already caught a glimpse of its distinctive and brilliantly drawn 2D art. That’s one way, and possibly the best way to describe, The Banner Saga – a collection of impressive artwork and a really engrossing fantasy-themed story packed into a neatly-crafted premise.

The Nordish-style setting has been selected especially, as part of the developer’s effort to evade the worn-out 'elves, dwarves & orcs' type of background. Ah, so I see that they didn’t take the Tolkien route. But aren’t Vikings overused as well? So, basically just chose not to avoid the Vikings. I’m sorry – the Varl. Or at least that’s what a race of giant warriors is called in the game. And don’t misunderstand me here. Despite the obvious inspiration found in Norse mythology, Stoic has done a really masterful job in setting up its own premise and events in a world that’s about to be torn to pieces by war.

There are several key characters that are being followed throughout the main story mode, including Rook, Hakon, Alette, Iver, Ubin, Oddleif and many others. These heroes are not voiced, which is a bit of a bummer. The dialogue system works just fine though. You’ll meet a variety of interesting individuals, some of which you stumble upon accidentally. Some may even be avoided completely, depending on the choices you make in the game. Others may even fall to their death if you make the wrong decision (or right decision, well, again that depends entirely on your own viewpoint).

Must warn you about the upcoming spoilers right now. One thing is certain, Gunnulf, one of my favorite characters, was met with a rather unfortunate ending, because I chose a very specific course of action in a crisis situation. Although I was enraged by this course of action, I decided not to reload my checkpoint for two reasons. The first reason is that I was determined to see my way through this course of the story that is determined by my own actions. The second reason is that it would require replaying an exceptionally long battle, which has already been victorious for me.

This brings me to the most crucial aspect of The Banner Saga – the combat. Battles have a recognizable turn-based feel to it, with the player being able to move soldiers across a grid-like battlefield. Battles can be exciting and extremely challenging. Opponents can be outsmarted with skilled use of ranged and melee units. That involves making the right moves and choosing whether to attack the enemy’s armor or health. That’s right, each unit on the battlefield has an exact number of armor points and health points. The sooner you drain the enemy’s armor, the easier it will be to take out its health. Of course, units also have their unique abilities and attacks that can reduce both armor and health. Still, a lot will depend on how you place your units. Archers and magic-wielding units are very vulnerable in close-combat so it’s important to keep them protected, and out of range of any sword-happy enemy warriors.

So, the battles themselves are quite satisfying. The problem comes if you want to retry a single battle and frequently you are forced to sit through a ton of dialogue, since the game for some odd reason doesn’t always autosave just before a battle, but more annoyingly, just before the beginning of a major dialogue scene.

Since The Banner Saga has all the elements of a fine turn-based strategy, we were a bit baffled by some very weird design choices, which we felt could’ve been avoided. For instance, to keep in line with the game’s storyline, the player rarely gets the opportunity to level up heroes and rebuild forces to gain more strength. You gain renown points by fighting and making important judgment calls before battle or during your travels. Renown points are utilized to promote heroes, but as I already explained, there’s not nearly enough opportunity to distribute these points.

Also, renown points are scarce and are also used for purchasing supplies, which are needed to feed your army. Also, the game has a tendency to take away characters unexpectedly. Just when I’ve got used to one character and his skills, the game shifts to a different plot point and I’m not allowed to upgrade that character anymore. Instead, I have to focus on a different group of characters. Normally, I don’t have anything against games shifting from one story to another. The problem is that during an entire playthrough that consists of a rather rich character roster, I only managed to improve one character to level 5. The rest never got passed level 2 or 3. This sort of defeats the purpose of having so many characters to upgrade and take into battle, simply because there are usually few renown points to spare.

The Banner Saga is a unique game, worthy of anyone’s attention. There is some gorgeous in-game artwork on display here, in addition to some rather delicious plot twists that could infuriate as easily as it can excite you. All the cool 2D art and well-written dialogue is accompanied by diverse ambient sound effects and an epic soundtrack that suits the Viking-style setting perfectly.

Regardless of some of our complaints, we invested many hours into this game, enjoying every bit of its refreshingly simple gameplay. We also couldn’t tear ourselves away from the breathtaking background drawings and impressive character art that portray a new and mysteriously beautiful world that awaits to be discoverd.


8.4   Very Good

Beautifully crafted 2D turn-based strategy with welcomed RPG elements, in addition to a rich and immersive fantasy setting;

Checkpoints can be annoying, promoting multiple heroes can take forever, the main campaign is relatively short.


6 post(s)
Reader Comments
im_stardust Feb 07 2014, 09:00 am EST
An exaggerated review. I swear you do this all the fucking time with something you like. "breathtaking", "epic", "mysteriously beautiful", "rich and immersive"...give me a fucking break!

The gameplay was weak. Very few rpg elements and not properly implemented. The overall design on the enemy soldiers could have been done much better. You don't really have enough points to buy items and promote soldiers, barely for one of them.

It's a inconsistent game made by newbies. The only thing good is the writing and the artwork/drawings.
Bubu Feb 07 2014, 09:15 am EST
The only thing that made me regret buying this is the fact that the developer said that this will be a self contained story with an ending .... and what did we get?! A FUCKING CLIFFHANGER!!!!! What's worst is that they didn't know if they will be able to continue the story with part 2 and 3. Fucking morons. Did they say anything about the sales? Will we get a continuation?
  Cheddar: Yes.
KraGeRzR Feb 07 2014, 02:08 pm EST
To paraphrase im_stardust: 8/10 it's horrible.
im_stardust Feb 07 2014, 04:24 pm EST
It ain't the score. It's his vocabulary! God damn it!
Vader [STAFF] Dec 23 2014, 05:30 am EST
I'll just copy-paste my sentence to annoy you even further. Also, I do love you all.

"Beautifully crafted 2D turn-based strategy with welcomed RPG elements"
Cheddar Mar 10 2015, 02:16 am EDT
This game is beautiful and tragic and epic.

I love it. So much.

(admittedly, it also probably helps that I'm old enough to have played Oregon Trail when I was kid)


Easily fill in your friends' emails to send them this page.

Which multiplayer shooter have you picked?

Neither, single-player FTW!
What are those? Never heard of them.
» view results
» view poll archives
Yooka-LayleeAgents of MayhemSkylanders ImaginatorsAbsolverVampyrPro Cycling Manager 2016
Perhaps Last But Not Penultimate ComicNever Lose FaithThe Winning Team

monitoring_string = "eff2d707bb70db01fa83ebd63e0c5947"